Podcast Videos

Benchmark Illusion: When Managers Deviate from the Index

Current Categories

Podcast, Videos

The Issue at Hand by Madison Investments

A bond fund’s benchmark can provide insight into what a portfolio may invest in and the risk and return characteristics it may exhibit. Selecting the right benchmark is often the starting point when allocating a portion of a client’s portfolio to fixed income, but understanding how the portfolio actually compares to that benchmark almost always requires further digging.

In this episode, Chris Aleman and Head of Fixed Income Mike Sanders take a closer look at fixed income benchmarks, including the Bloomberg Aggregate Bond Index, how portfolios may deviate from their benchmarks in pursuit of outperformance, and how advisors can assess whether a portfolio’s risks and return characteristics actually align with a client’s needs.

Key Takeaways

  • How fixed income indexes differ from equity indexes and what that means for managing a bond portfolio.
  • The levers a manager can pull to deviate from the benchmark and seek outperformance.
  • Why advisors shouldn’t assume a portfolio looks like its benchmark simply because the benchmark appears in the prospectus.
  • How to determine whether a fund or portfolio has a similar risk profile and return pattern to its benchmark.
  • The questions an advisor should ask their bond manager.

The Discussion

Mike Sanders: If you go through life assuming the worst is going to happen, you get surprised on the upside.

Chris Aleman: We’re all going to get depressed if we continue to listen to him.

Chris Aleman: Hello and welcome back to another episode of The Issue at Hand. I’m Chris Aleman, and I’m joined by Head of Fixed Income, Mike Sanders. Tough loss for both of our teams, I’d say, huh, Mike?

Mike Sanders: Not a good week. Not a good week.

Chris Aleman: You didn’t lose with seven seconds left on the clock.

Mike Sanders No, the Packers were just bad the entire game, so.

Chris Aleman: Well, that’s fair – that is fair. Alright, well, enough about our teams because I think we’ll get a little too off topic. Let’s stick with fixed income.

Now we’ve already talked about risk, credit, duration, liquidity structure, active versus passive. We’ve already covered a lot of that in our previous episodes. But I think we need to take a step back and talk about where an advisor starts to have that conversation with their client about fixed income in general. Where do we start?

Mike Sanders: I think it really comes down to defining the objectives for your client and then trying to find a benchmark that best reflects those risks and the return possibilities. If you have a certain client that is okay with more or less interest rate risk, that’s going to push you into a specific index.

Hopefully the manager or the strategy you select follows that return pattern because you’re choosing an index based upon your clients’ risks and the returns that they would like – make sure that’s what’s getting invested in.

Chris Aleman: But wait a minute, you mentioned index and benchmarking. I think one of the things that you need to point out again is that there is a difference between an equity index and a fixed income index. So, what is that key difference?

Mike Sanders: The biggest difference, from how I look at it, is in equity land, the companies that have better performance, their stock price goes up, and then that’s going to over time become a bigger and bigger portion of the index.

For bonds and bond indices, it’s kind of the opposite – not the opposite – but it’s more and more debt gets you a larger percentage on in the index, which may or may not be what you want. Think about treasuries today, or mortgages back in the crisis, or corporates – whatever the index is – the more you issue, the bigger representation you’re going to have in the index. And again, that’s not necessarily good or bad. It’s just, you’re going to choose a manager then to assess those risks. Again, ideally in a framework that’s going to have performance patterns roughly in line with the index, hopefully beat the index, but then not take so much risk you’re swinging one way or the other.

Chris Aleman: Well, hang on, let’s focus on the last point, because what you’re saying is not taking all that risk. So, what are some of the things that we should factor in? I guess something that’s maybe embedded in the index, or maybe even like a false sense of security. I don’t know – what are some of those things that we should be looking for?

Mike Sanders: Let’s take the Agg (Bloomberg Aggregate Bond Index), which is probably the most well-known index. It’s six years, give or take, a lot of treasuries, corporates, and mortgage securities for the most part. You could have managers that have durations massively different than the benchmark – half the duration of the benchmark or more of the duration of the benchmark, way more treasuries, way less corporates – whatever the combination is, and depending on the market, you’re going to have vastly different performance versus the index.

Now, again, I think ideally you want to have the return stream somewhat similar to the benchmark you’re choosing. Because again, it’s going back to your clients’ risk preferences. And so you just have to make sure when you’re looking at the levers that can get pulled, the sources of alpha, that it’s not so dissimilar to the index.

Chris Aleman: I think some of the things that you point out don’t seem like, to your point, it’s necessarily a bad thing. So, is an index flawed, or is how we’re thinking about it flawed?

Mike Sanders: I don’t know if flawed is the right word to use. I think it’s a representation of the fixed income market. The Agg is the representation of investment-grade US bonds – whatever they are. Now you can have preferences within that universe of possible bonds, but again, if you want a representation of the entire fixed income market here in the United States, you should hopefully be investing in securities that are similar to that, that have kind of the same return pattern. If you don’t care, then choose a different index or a different manager. But if you’re choosing an index, you should have some similar performance patterns. Otherwise, you have no idea what you’re going to get.

Chris Aleman: I want to tug on that one just a little bit because I agree with you, I don’t think it’s flawed. And I go back to the financial crisis like 2008 – the index was overweight the financial sector, which was completely distressed at the time, which was getting exposed. What are we looking at today? Whether it’s AI issuance, hyperscalers, industrials, or anything like that. What is the current makeup today so people understand that it’s not flawed, it’s just what the reality of the issuers are today.

Mike Sanders: A hundred percent. You have a lot of Treasury issuance, you have massive amount of government spending, you have the hyperscalers that are issuing a lot of different debt. And again, there are no bad bonds, just bad bond prices. And so, you can still hire a manager that can assess those risks but still provide you with some performance that should be similar to the benchmark and outperform the benchmark without investing in stuff that’s not anywhere in the benchmark. It’s not really a fair comparison to own a bunch of bank loans and compare yourself to the Agg. Hopefully the advisor is not looking and trying to compare an Agg performance versus a bank loan portfolio. It’s not really what you should be looking at.

Just buy a bank loan manager and know that that’s what they’re investing in. Hopefully they’re not saying, “well, they’re exposed to the Agg, and therefore I should have similar performance”. You’re not going to get the same. So just making sure you understand your risks and the possible outcomes for performance. I think that’s the biggest key.

Chris Aleman: Well, one of the things that you just said, and I get questioned a lot is: what happens when an issue gets downgraded? Is it price movement, is at risk, et cetera? What exactly happens with the issuer’s debt when the issuer’s debt is downgraded? What happens to the makeup of the index, that sort of thing?

Mike Sanders: So, it gets booted out of the index. And so that creates opportunities possibly to own it after it gets downgraded. Maybe it’s still attractive relative to other securities, and you can still own that and then still benefit from performance. Indexing in fixed income’s a tough road to do that because you have some of those rules that you’re having bonds in and out that don’t necessarily reflect value when they come in and out. But I think that’s the part where again, you can still have a broad exposure to securities that make up the Agg but still have the opportunity to make these small investment decisions at the edges to generate the performance while still having the integrity of the portfolio act like how it should.

Chris Aleman: I think that makes sense, and I think we’ve beat the makeup of the index as far as we could go. So, I guess let’s start with index selection when it comes to managers. Why does it matter so much that managers in the asset class have different benchmarks? Why does it matter when evaluating them if one manager says I want this index, the other one wants a different index? Why does it matter?

Mike Sanders: I think it matters so you can properly judge how well the manager does. You can game an index and have a completely different asset class, and it’ll do well sometimes, and it’ll do poorly other times. So, if you’re going to properly assess whether somebody’s good at investing in fixed income, I think you have to compare it to what it’s really investing in. And so that’s the biggest key.

At certain points in time, a specific asset class will do really well or really poorly. But if you’re not comparing that manager to the correct index, you’re going to get signals that aren’t going to really match with what you want that portfolio to do. And a lot of those misrepresentations show up when you don’t want them to. It shows up when volatility really hits. It shows up when COVID happens and spreads massively widen out and your bonds are negative performance at the same time your equities are down. I mean that’s not really why you own fixed income. You wanted bonds to help when rates fell and there was uncertainty. Instead, you have managers that owned everything but what’s in the Agg, and you have this massive swing in performance. It’s just so you understand what you’re investing in and you understand the possible outcomes that you can get.

And again, there’s no issue with not owning what’s in the index and owning other securities, but then I think as the advisor you have to understand why that’s the case. Is it consistently the case? And if so, then maybe it needs to be a different portion of your client’s portfolio. It’s not really a good representation of the broad fixed income market. It’s a representation of a smaller part of it, which doesn’t mean it’s good or bad. It’s just that you’re not going to get what you think you’re going to get.

Chris Aleman: When I get questions, sometimes when I look at manager performance, a lot of the time it’s: how liquid am I? Do they have leverage?

Because when they actually look at the holdings, sometimes it’s not exactly what they were supposed to own. So I think that’s always an interesting thing to look at. So, let’s stick with the financial advisor theme.

If I’m an advisor sitting across from a client or prospect looking at their bond allocation, I think we’ve covered some of them, but can you lay out the questions that they should be asking? Maybe four or five points?

Mike Sanders: First of all, what’s the benchmark? What does it own? The flaws of the index? Does it own too much of certain securities, which is not necessarily a positive, more debt? How does the portfolio itself differ from the benchmark? Going back to the Agg, if you have an Agg strategy and the portfolio doesn’t own any Treasuries at all, then that should be a red flag in reality because it’s not really going to be anywhere close to the performance of the Agg.

And then from that, where is the manager taking its active risk? Credit, duration, liquidity, structure, etc.? And then how is that historically played out in terms of performance? And so, what’s the downside if it doesn’t work out? Because again, I think the best investors are risk managers first, and I think that’s how you should be looking at it. Because bonds- you get a hundred cents back, and you get a lot less if it doesn’t work out. So you have to always look at the downside.

Chris Aleman: Well, one of the ones you just mentioned, the Barclays Agg, when I talk to FAs, I’ve dealt with this before, and they see the Barclays Agg and they assume that the manager is similar to that, that they’re going to be investing very similarly. Exactly what you’re laying out. So you’re saying, don’t just stop there when you see it. You need to do a little bit more, right?

Mike Sanders: A hundred percent. You really need to understand where the money’s getting invested and don’t assume that because a benchmark is on the prospectus or whatever they’re stating, that that’s more or less are investing in. There are a lot of different securities out there, and they don’t have to necessarily own the benchmark-ish type bonds, and that’s what you have to be afraid of. Because again, it might not work out.

Chris Aleman: Well, I think those are good questions, Mike, but how, as an advisor, how do they actually understand what any of that means? How do they go about looking at some of these things?

Mike Sanders: In fixed income, I think a great place to look would be just in credit, in your credit exposure. And like I had mentioned, the Agg is investment grade fixed income in the United States. Well, if you look at a lot of managers out there, a lot of other strategies that supposedly follow the Agg have 10, 20, 30 percent high yield in it. And there’s nothing wrong with that. But is that really what you’re getting when you are outperforming against the Agg? You’re just getting high-yield exposure. And that’s going to be correlated to the equity market. Those are the kind of clues when you’re looking at managers’ allocation and then performance patterns – I’m not even saying it has to be a red flag, it just has to be something that you’re aware of. The last thing you want is to buy an Agg manager that has 25% high yield, and then all of a sudden you want to allocate more to a specific high yield manager, and next thing you know your supposedly safe fixed income portfolio is a bunch of high yield bonds. Nothing wrong with that. Just make sure you know that that’s the case.

Chris Aleman: Even if they use that index, you’ve got to make sure, read the fine print, see if they actually say it, because that might be what they’re doing, but you need to actually be able to see those things.

Well, let’s wrap it up there. I want to thank everyone for joining us today. Mike, thanks for your insight. And one of the things I always tell people: please don’t forget to click subscribe. If you want to hear more information about The Issue at Hand, insights, additional disclosures, or even some of the questions and characteristics you should be looking for out of your manager, please visit MadisonInvestments.com. Thanks again, take care.

Related Posts

Upon request, Madison may furnish to the client or institution a list of all security recommendations made within the past year.

Although the information, including index information, in this report has been obtained from sources that the firm believes to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy, and any such information may be incomplete or condensed. All opinions included in the report constitute the authors’ judgment as of the date of this report and are subject to change without notice.  This report is for informational purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security.

In addition to the ongoing market risk applicable to portfolio securities, bonds are subject to interest rate risk, credit risk and inflation risk. When interest rates rise, bond prices fall; generally, the longer a bond’s maturity, the more sensitive it is to this risk. Credit risk is the possibility that the issuer of a security will be unable to make interest payments and repay the principal on its debt. Bonds may also be subject to call risk, which allows the issuer to retain the right to redeem the debt, fully or partially, before the scheduled maturity date. Proceeds from sales prior to maturity may be more or less than originally invested due to changes in market conditions or changes in the credit quality of the issuer.

Equity risk is the risk that securities held by the fund will fluctuate in value due to general market or economic conditions, perceptions regarding the industries in which the issuers of securities held by the fund participate, and the particular circumstances and performance of particular companies whose securities the fund holds. In addition, while broad market measures of common stocks have historically generated higher average returns than fixed income securities, common stocks have also experienced significantly more volatility in those returns.

Indices are unmanaged. An investor cannot invest directly in an index. They are shown for illustrative purposes only, and do not represent the performance of any specific investment. Index returns do not include any expenses, fees or sales charges, which would lower performance.

The Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index (formerly known as the Barclays Agg) is a broad-based flagship benchmark that measures the investment grade, U.S. dollar-denominated, fixed-rate taxable bond market. The index includes Treasuries, government-related and corporate securities, mortgage backed securities, asset-backed securities and corporate securities, with maturities greater than one year.

Alpha: a measure of the excess return of an investment relative to the return of its benchmark index. A positive alpha indicates outperformance, while a negative alpha suggests underperformance.

Duration is a measure of the sensitivity of the price of a bond or other debt instrument to a change in interest rates. Duration measures how long it takes, in years, for an investor to be repaid the bond’s price by the bond’s total cash flows.

High-Yield Bonds: Also known as junk bonds, high-yield bonds are bonds issued by companies that are considered to be at a greater risk of failing to make interest and principal payments on schedule.

Spread is the yield difference between a Treasury bond and a bond of the same duration that has additional risks, such as a corporate bond.

Volatility is the degree of variation of returns for a given security or market index.